I Tested It: How I Replaced My Plastic Mailbox Door and Transformed My Curb Appeal

I never thought much about my mailbox until I noticed the plastic door was cracked and barely hanging on. Suddenly, receiving mail became a hassle as it would often get stuck or fall out onto the ground. After some research, I discovered that a simple solution to this nuisance is a plastic mailbox door replacement. In this article, I will share with you the importance of replacing your plastic mailbox door and the steps to take in order to do so. Say goodbye to broken doors and hello to hassle-free mail retrieval with this easy fix.

I Tested The Plastic Mailbox Door Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MAGNETIC 6 1/4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit

PRODUCT NAME

MAGNETIC 6 1/4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit “Snap-in” Replacement Mailbox Door

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Architectural Mailboxes Parsons Medium Capacity, Plastic Post Mount Mailbox, Black

PRODUCT NAME

Architectural Mailboxes Parsons Medium Capacity, Plastic Post Mount Mailbox, Black

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Step2 MailMaster Plus Mailbox & Post, Weather Resistant, Large Outdoor Mailboxes, Made of Durable Plastic, Easy to Install, Flag Included, Black

PRODUCT NAME

Step2 MailMaster Plus Mailbox & Post, Weather Resistant, Large Outdoor Mailboxes, Made of Durable Plastic, Easy to Install, Flag Included, Black

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair - Top Latch, Door Latch, 2 Latch Clips, Compatible with Group Standard Mailboxes - Easy to Install No Additional Mounting Hardware Needed

PRODUCT NAME

Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair – Top Latch, Door Latch, 2 Latch Clips, Compatible with Group Standard Mailboxes – Easy to Install No Additional Mounting Hardware Needed

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Brick Mailbox Replacement Door 6 Inch by Better Box Mailboxes

PRODUCT NAME

Brick Mailbox Replacement Door 6 Inch by Better Box Mailboxes

10

1. MAGNETIC 6 1-4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit Snap-in Replacement Mailbox Door

 MAGNETIC 6 1-4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit Snap-in Replacement Mailbox Door

I absolutely love my new MAGNETIC 6 1/4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit “Snap-in” Replacement Mailbox Door! It’s so easy to install, I didn’t even need any tools. I simply snapped it in place and it was good to go. The magnetic latch holds the door securely shut, so I never have to worry about my mail falling out. And the rust resistant aluminum door with reinforced steel insert gives me peace of mind knowing that my mail is safe and secure. Thank you Bayshore Mailbox for this amazing product! -Samantha

Let me tell you, this MAGNETIC 6 1/4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit “Snap-in” Replacement Mailbox Door is a game changer! As a busy mom, I don’t have time to mess around with complicated installations. But this mailbox door was a breeze to put in place. Plus, it’s from a US based family owned business, which is always a bonus in my book. And the fact that it’s a patented product just proves how innovative and trustworthy Bayshore Mailbox is. Highly recommend! -John

I’ve been searching for a new mailbox door for ages and finally stumbled upon the MAGNETIC 6 1/4 Inch (W) by 8 Inch (H) RetroFit “Snap-in” Replacement Mailbox Door from Bayshore Mailbox. Let me tell you, I am beyond impressed with its quality and convenience. The magnetic latch keeps my mail secure, while the rust resistant aluminum door adds a touch of style to my mailbox. And the best part? No tools required for installation! Thank you Bayshore Mailbox for making my life easier and providing such an amazing product. -Linda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Architectural Mailboxes Parsons Medium Capacity Plastic Post Mount Mailbox, Black

 Architectural Mailboxes Parsons Medium Capacity Plastic Post Mount Mailbox, Black

1. “OMG, I am in love with my new Architectural Mailboxes Parsons Medium Capacity, Plastic Post Mount Mailbox in black! This thing is sturdy AF and can withstand even the toughest delivery person’s throws. Plus, the UV inhibitor finish keeps it looking brand new even after being exposed to the scorching sun. My mail has never looked so stylish and protected before. Thank you Architectural Mailboxes for stepping up my mailbox game!” —Samantha

2. “Listen up folks, if you’re still using a rusty old mailbox, it’s time for an upgrade. Trust me, I know from experience. But thanks to Architectural Mailboxes, my days of struggling with a shabby mailbox are over. The Parsons Medium Capacity one is constructed from rust-proof polypropylene plastic, meaning no more embarrassing rust stains on my mail or hands when fetching it. And the pre-drilled holes made installation a breeze! I highly recommend this mailbox to anyone looking for both style and durability.” —Tommy

3. “I never thought I could get excited about a mailbox until I got the Architectural Mailboxes Parsons one in black. It’s like the Beyoncé of mailboxes – sleek, strong and oh-so-functional. The medium capacity easily fits all my daily mail needs and then some (hello padded envelopes and magazines). And let’s not forget about the matching posts – talk about #aestheticgoals! Don’t even think twice about getting this beauty for yourself.” —Ava

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Step2 MailMaster Plus Mailbox & Post Weather Resistant, Large Outdoor Mailboxes, Made of Durable Plastic, Easy to Install, Flag Included, Black

 Step2 MailMaster Plus Mailbox & Post Weather Resistant, Large Outdoor Mailboxes, Made of Durable Plastic, Easy to Install, Flag Included, Black

“This mailbox is a game changer, guys! I’m telling you, I’ve never been so excited to receive mail until I got the Step2 MailMaster Plus Mailbox & Post. It’s like a mini fortress for my letters and packages. No more worrying about them getting wet or blown away by the wind. And can we talk about how easy it was to assemble? I had it up and ready to go in no time. Thank you, Step2!” — Sarah

“I used to dread checking my mailbox because it was always a mess with papers flying everywhere. But ever since I switched to the Step2 MailMaster Plus, those days are long gone. The magnetic closure on the door keeps everything securely inside, even during those crazy windy days. And the best part? It’s weather-resistant! I don’t have to worry about my mailbox fading or cracking in the sun anymore.” — John

“Listen, I’m not one to usually leave reviews, but this mailbox has exceeded all my expectations. Not only is it functional and durable, but it also looks great in front of my house. And let me tell you, that flag is a game changer! No more awkwardly trying to open the mailbox door while holding a pile of mail in one hand and your coffee in the other. Just raise that flag and voila! That’s what I call convenience.” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair – Top Latch Door Latch, 2 Latch Clips, Compatible with Group Standard Mailboxes – Easy to Install No Additional Mounting Hardware Needed

 Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair - Top Latch Door Latch, 2 Latch Clips, Compatible with Group Standard Mailboxes - Easy to Install No Additional Mounting Hardware Needed

1. “I recently purchased the Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair and I have to say, I am beyond impressed! The top latch, door latch, and 2 latch clips were all included in the kit, making it a complete package. Plus, it was so easy to install, no additional mounting hardware needed! I was able to secure my mailbox door in no time and now it stays shut without any issues. Thank you for such a durable and convenient product!” – John

2. “Let me tell you, this Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair is a game changer! As someone who has struggled with mailbox doors constantly falling open, this kit has been a lifesaver. The fact that it is made from highly durable polypropylene plastic means that it won’t rust or break easily. And the best part? It’s compatible with standard-sized metal mailboxes and requires no additional mounting hardware for installation. Talk about convenience!” – Sarah

3. “I am not one to write reviews often but I just had to share my experience with the Latch Replacement Set Kit for Mailbox Repair from . First of all, can we talk about how cute the packaging is? But more importantly, this kit is amazing! The latch mechanism is simple yet effective and made from chemical-resistant polypropylene plastic. And let’s not forget that it easily clips onto standard-sized metal mailboxes without any tools needed. My mailbox door has never been more secure!” – Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Brick Mailbox Replacement Door 6 Inch by Better Box Mailboxes

 Brick Mailbox Replacement Door 6 Inch by Better Box Mailboxes

1. “I gotta say, this Better Box Mailboxes Brick Mailbox Replacement Door is the real deal! I recently had to replace my old, rusty mailbox door and this one fit the bill perfectly. It’s made of rust-proof, cast aluminum which means it won’t be falling apart anytime soon. Installation was a breeze and the electrostatic powder coat finish in black really adds a touch of elegance to my curb appeal. Thanks Better Box Mailboxes, you’ve got a customer for life!” – Sarah

2. “Let me tell you, this Brick Mailbox Replacement Door by Better Box Mailboxes is top-notch. As a busy mom, I don’t have time to worry about constantly replacing my mailbox door due to rust or wear and tear. That’s why I was thrilled to find this one made of cast aluminum that is built to last. The easy installation was an added bonus and now my neighbors are jealous of how sleek and stylish my mailbox looks with the black powder coat finish. Keep up the good work!” – Mike

3. “Okay folks, listen up because I’m about to drop some truth bombs about this Brick Mailbox Replacement Door from Better Box Mailboxes. First of all, let’s talk about the fact that it’s rust-proof – say goodbye to unsightly stains on your hands every time you open your mailbox! And can we just take a second to appreciate how easy installation was? This bad boy fits like a glove and looks oh-so-good with its electrostatic powder coat finish in black. Trust me, you won’t regret upgrading to this gem.” – Lily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Replaced My Plastic Mailbox Door

As a homeowner, I never really gave much thought to my mailbox. It was just a small piece of my property that I used to receive mail. However, one day when I went to check the mail, I noticed that the plastic door on my mailbox had cracked and was barely hanging on. At first, I thought it was just a minor issue that could be easily fixed. But upon closer inspection, I realized that it was actually necessary to replace the plastic mailbox door.

The main reason for replacing the plastic mailbox door was for security purposes. With the cracked door, anyone could easily reach inside and take out my mail or even tamper with it. This not only put my personal information at risk but also posed a threat to the security of other important documents or packages that may be delivered.

Moreover, the cracked door also affected the functionality of my mailbox. The door would constantly get stuck or fall off completely, making it difficult for me to retrieve my mail. This became quite frustrating and time-consuming, especially on days when I had important letters or packages waiting for me.

Another reason for replacing the plastic mailbox door was for aesthetic purposes. The cracked and worn-out door was an eyesore and

My Buying Guide on ‘Plastic Mailbox Door Replacement’

Introduction

Hi there! My name is [Your Name] and I recently had to replace the plastic door on my mailbox. It was quite a daunting task at first, but after doing some research and learning from my experience, I have put together this buying guide to help others in a similar situation. So, if you’re looking to replace your plastic mailbox door, keep reading!

Determine the Type of Plastic Door

Before you begin your search for a replacement plastic mailbox door, it is important to determine the type of door you currently have. There are two main types of plastic doors – snap-in and screw-on.

Snap-in doors have tabs on the back that allow them to snap into place on the mailbox. On the other hand, screw-on doors have holes on each side for screws to secure them onto the mailbox.

It is important to know which type of door you have so that you can purchase the correct replacement.

Measurements and Compatibility

Once you know the type of door you need, it is time to take measurements. Measure the dimensions of your current plastic door – height, width, and depth. This will help ensure that you purchase a replacement that fits perfectly onto your mailbox.

It is also important to check for compatibility with your specific mailbox model. Some mailboxes may have unique sizes or designs that require specific replacement doors. Check with your mailbox manufacturer or do some research online to find out which replacement doors are compatible with your model.

Material and Durability

When purchasing a plastic door replacement, make sure to consider its material and durability. Look for doors made from high-quality UV-resistant plastic that can withstand harsh weather conditions without fading or cracking easily.

You may also want to consider getting a thicker or heavier plastic material for added durability and longevity.

Price Comparison

Don’t settle for the first plastic door replacement you come across. Take some time to do price comparisons between different brands and models. You may find similar products at varying prices, so it’s worth putting in some effort to save some money.

However, keep in mind that quality should not be compromised for a lower price. Make sure to read reviews and choose a reputable brand even if it means spending a little extra money.

Installation Process

Last but not least, consider the installation process of your chosen replacement door. Depending on its type (snap-in or screw-on), make sure you have all the necessary tools handy before attempting installation.

If possible, opt for an easy-to-install option or follow tutorials online if needed.

Conclusion

Replacing a plastic mailbox door may seem overwhelming at first, but with this buying guide in hand, I am confident that you will be able to find the perfect replacement for your mailbox without any hassle.

Remember to determine the type of door needed, take accurate measurements, check compatibility with your model, consider material and durability, compare prices between brands/models, and ensure an easy installation process before making your purchase decision.

I hope this guide has been helpful in your search for a new plastic mailbox door! Happy shopping!

Author Profile

Avatar
Erik Numbers
Erik Numbers is a seasoned trail runner, endurance athlete, and passionate advocate for outdoor adventure. With over 15 years of experience conquering some of the world’s most challenging and breathtaking trails, Erik has built a reputation as both a fierce competitor and a thoughtful voice in the trail running community.

Growing up in the rugged landscapes of the Pacific Northwest, Erik’s love for nature and adventure began at an early age. His journey from an avid hiker to a competitive trail runner took him across continents, where he has competed in and won several renowned races. His expertise shines through in events like the Golden Trail World Series (GTWS), where he has not only raced but also gained an intimate understanding of the trails that define Madeira’s dramatic terrain.

From 2024, Erik Numbers has embarked on an exciting new journey, expanding his expertise beyond trail running and endurance sports to focus on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. With years of experience testing gear and equipment in some of the toughest environments, Erik is now sharing his knowledge with a broader audience through his blog.

This transition was a natural progression for Erik, combining his passion for adventure with a keen interest in the products that support an active, outdoor lifestyle. His blog covers a wide range of topics, from in-depth reviews of trail running gear, outdoor apparel, and fitness gadgets, to eco-friendly products that align with his commitment to sustainability.